The most intriguing of the offerings, at least to me, is 'Going Dutch' on FOX, which premiered on January 2, 2025. In the series, "After an epically unfiltered rant, an arrogant, loudmouth U.S. Army Colonel is reassigned to the Netherlands, where he is punished with a command position at the least important army base in the world. After serving with distinction in every warzone of the last three decades, he now finds himself in charge of a base with no guns, no weapons and no tactical purpose. Instead, it has a Michelin-star-level commissary, top-notch bowling alley and the best (and only) fromagerie in the U.S. Army. Surrounded by a diverse group of underdogs, the colonel tries to reinstall military discipline and professionalism with the help of the base's previous interim leader, who just happens to be his estranged daughter." With a score of 86% on Rotten Tomatoes, the ensemble cast includes Danny Pudi, Denis Leary, and Joe Morton. But what did the critics say?
Joel Keller of Decider says, "There’s potential in Going Dutch, though the pilot was less funny than we expected, given the presence of Leary and Pudi. Denis and Jack Leary are among the executive producers, with Joel Church-Cooper as the showrunner. Church-Cooper’s past series, with Brockmire being the most prominent, indicate to us that the potential we saw in this first episode is what is going to help it improve over time. In the first scenes, where the old-fashioned, un-PC-but-trying Col. Quinn can’t seem to process how he landed at Stroopsdorf, we get mostly standard gags about the tough commander railing against the perceived “soft” troops he’s inherited. Then there’s a scene when Patrick and Maggie have an actual heart-to-heart talk about their relationship, and how Patrick acknowledges that they’ll have to mesh their respective styles, where the potential of this show reveals itself. Leary is especially good in this scene, recalling his best work in his best-known series, Rescue Me. What we hope is that Church-Cooper can refine the show so that the “hard-ass commander vs. ragtag troops” trope becomes grounded more in character than anything else. There were a couple of chuckleworthy moments where we see soldiers making cheese and other non-military activities, but we know that for Going Dutch to succeed, we’re going to have to explore all the characters beyond what we saw in the pilot."
On the opposite side of the coin, 'Beast Games' on Prime Video is a complete mess. In the series, "1,000 contestants compete in physical, mental and social challenges, for a chance to win a five million dollar cash prize; contestants use their strength and wit to stay in the game, with the hope of being the multi-million-dollar winner." Critics were quick to give it a score of 14% on Rotten Tomatoes, but what did they say?
Chase Hutchinson of IGN Movies writes, "Beast Games isn’t just surprisingly dull. It's also almost entirely devoid of anything to get invested in. Though future episodes may delve deeper into competitors’ personalities and motivations – the bread and butter of any reality show – once their ranks are whittled down, the beginning of the series is so impatiently frenetic that we’re barely introduced to any of them. Some of this, again, carries over from YouTube, where MrBeast’s output often feels like a bunch of TikTok videos crammed together out of fear that you’ll get bored unless something new is thrown in your face right this second. But Beast Games is uniquely out of its depth. The spread of games is vast – they include contestants trying to convince their teammates to eliminate themselves and a block-stacking challenge – but they all prioritize breadth over depth. The ones that could be more psychologically tense have no weight, passing with breakneck speed so we can get to the next one then the next one and so on. They all feel like they were made up in five minutes, and there’s nothing memorable about them aside from how they steal the iconography and callousness of Squid Game. An ongoing TV series requires more than a YouTuber bludgeoning his audience with reminders of what’s at stake. Even when Beast Games stumbles into a potentially fun challenge – like a trivia game where we get to see the personalities of the players briefly shine through – each sequence is so edited to pieces that you don’t actually feel any of its impact. It’s headache-inducing rather than anything close to harrowing or humorous. When Donaldson jumps in to brag via voiceover how they have thousands of cameras on set (a weird flex if there ever was one), it made me wish he had fewer. An editor who could’ve built some breathing room into the proceedings would’ve been nice, too."
 |
| Photo by Georgia Vagim on Unsplash |
No comments:
Post a Comment