On August 14, 2024, Netflix released 'American Murder: Laci Peterson', which has received predominantly positive reviews from critics. In the documentary series, the infamous 2002 case of Laci Peterson is introduced to a whole new generation. But what exactly did the critics say?
Randy Myers of San Jose Mercury News writes, "It’s been just over two decades since a 27-year-old pregnant Modesto woman with an megawatt smile disappeared on Christmas Eve and whose remains washed up near the Berkeley Marina. Laci Peterson’s 2003 death at the hands of her husband became one of the most closely watched crime cases in recent history. It’s a story that remains forever etched in the public consciousness. But is there a real need to dredge it all up again? Is there anything legitimately new to add to a heartbreaking tragedy about the killing of Peterson and her unborn son Conner, given the relentless media scrutiny that came before? After all, we know well — perhaps too well — the shocking developments and players: the handsome philandering fertilizer salesman Scott Peterson tagged as the prime suspect, his unsuspecting Fresno girlfriend Amber Frey stepping forward to reveal critical info, the red herring in the form of a burglary next door to where Laci and Scott lived, and then that gruesome discovery." Adding, "Nothing here could exactly be called a critical revelation (perhaps Frey’s interview comes close). So after viewing this very watchable, thankfully un-sensational series composed of video clips and interviews with investigators and reporters and so on, you’ll likely be left with one impression:that justice was indeed served. To her credit, Borgman does offer time to those who maintain Scott is innocent, although Scott himself is not interviewed."
Geek Vibes Nation's M.N. Miller says, "This Netflix offering presents a measured approach, delivering insight and suspense for those unfamiliar with one of the most infamous American murder cases of the 21st century." Concluding, "The docuseries does offer a critical eye on both sides, such as having Scott Peterson’s family talk about some of the media onslaught around the case. For instance, I remember watching the Dean Cain television film about the case, depicting the accused hiding from police and making a run for the Mexican border. In reality, as his sister explains, he simply went to stay with family in San Diego to escape the relentless coverage. There are some moments from local detectives that I found alarming. They seem to tie their biases to the accused based on that person being hungry for fast food and viewing relief when the missing body is not recovered when he could have been relieved, you know, that his wife and unborn child are not dead. I would expect more from law enforcement when arresting someone for murder."
Romey Norton of Ready Steady Cut notes, "Through courtroom camera and interrogation footage, news clips, and exclusive interviews this Netflix docuseries sheds light on one of America’s most infamous true-crime cases" Continuing, "As true crime documentaries go, American Murder: Laci Peterson is gripping and grievous. Even though it’s a tragic story, the ending gives a slight ray of hope. Her family, friends, and people involved in this case remember Laci for the wonderful person she was and find comfort in her killer being in prison for life."
![]() |
Photo by Adrian Swancar on Unsplash |
No comments:
Post a Comment